There’s a saying that authors have to make the worst thing they possibly can happen to their characters. In these comments, Eric basically says the same thing has to happen with technology. It can’t develop smoothly, there need to be problems for the stories to be interesting.
It can be very frustrating to either get no feedback or to get a slew of negative feedback on a story you worked hard on. One of the comments here notes that tech problems are ignored in poorly written stories because they won’t be published, so they don’t take the time to review them. Good writers are more likely to be raked over the coals to get their story over the line to be published. In my personal experience, it seems like a lot of readers don’t comment if they either don’t see anything that needs to be improved or they see a massive, waving red flag or three.
– Bethanne Kim (Publisher, Eric Flint’s 1632 & Beyond magazine)
Baens Bar
Question: This started from a story in slush. The editor-in-chief at that time responded with a laundry list of problems and said that it was definitely not going to be published. It was harsh (which doesn’t mean it was either undeserved or off base) and clearly hard for the author to swallow. These are some of the comments that came from it.
11 November 2010 20:09
The basic mistake is mine, anyway. I wasn’t paying enough attention to all the technical developments emerging in a lot of different stories writyten by a number of authors because I was pre-occupied with other book projects, and by the time I finally realized that tech developments had ballooned quite a bit further than I really wanted or thought was plausible, it was a done deal.
I can pull back a lot of it just by individualizing the issues. (I.e., so-and-so managed to pull off building Gadget X partly because they just got lucky. The next eight people who tried died horribly.) But that’s why I’m clamping down now. The reason your story is getting singled out is actually because it’s the best case around — it’s well-written and the tech stuff is quite interesting. There’s an old saying that bad cases make bad law, and that’s essentially the principle at work here.
11 November 2010 15:56
Your story is well-written but I found it completely unbelievable. COMPLETELY. My suspension of disbelief began somewhere on page 2 and kept growing. There is no way in God’s green earth I would authorize this story for publication. That’s true for dramatic reasons as well as technical ones, by the way, which I will try to explain briefly.
I’ll start with the technical issues. You can argue until the cows come home that any one of the multitude of technological advances that you need for this story to work are plausible. Maybe so, although I’m skeptical and I largely agree with Walt on the specifics involved.
But ALL OF THEM???? Each and every single technological advance you posit in the story? In three or four years?
And they all have to work — in the bare minimum of time possible, with no significant problems at any point along the way — or the logic of your story collapses entirely.
That’s utterly impossible. I’m sorry, it just is.
What Really Bugged Eric
I have grown increasingly disturbed by the tendency of authors writing for the Gazette to keep pushing the tech development WITH NO SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS. That’s what really bugs me. I can accept airships being developed as quickly as they have, for instance, although I’m skeptical of some of the timetables. But why aren’t they suffering anything remotely close to the horrendous accident and fatality rates that early aviation was actually subject to? Why does everything always work the first time around?
I’ve probably been guilty of some of that myself, at least to a degree, and I’m planning to start correcting it. But it’s starting to get completely out of hand. That’s why I asked Walt to form the Council of Tech.
By the way, my original title for that was Council of Trent, because I told Walt I wanted a goddam counter-reformation. 🙂
Then there is the dramatic aspect of your story, which drives in exactly the wrong direction from my point of view. I found the idea of a mercenary air force quite intriguing, in and of itself, and I’d be willing to accept something along the rough lines of your story that takes longer and is technically less ambitious. But from the very beginning of this series I’ve steered away from turning it into a technical arms race type of story. There are a lot of reasons for that, one of them being that I think most of the romanticism about high tech weaponry is just that, romanticism — and pretty damn stupid romanticism at that. Sorry, but I came of age during the Vietnam War. I know who had the fancy tech in that war and who didn’t — and who won. And I’ve never seen anything since that changes my opinion that wars — much less broad social, political, economic and religious conflicts — are not won primarily by advanced weaponry.
But there’s a dramatic side of the question that’s more important. I find tech-driven stories boring. It’s as simple as that.And I think most readers do, as well.
As an aside, I also didn’t like to coincidence of the USE developing an aircraft that could handle the new French interceptor — and just in the nick of time. Yes, I know that’s not completely implausible. What the hell, it DID happen at least once in history, when the Monitor showed up to deal with the Virginia the day after the Confederate ironclad wreaked havoc on a Union fleet.
But it’s not very likely, is it? And what’s more important from my point of view is that I don’t want it dramatically. I WANT THE BAD GUYS TO WIN FROM TIME TO TIME. Fairly often, in fact. I’ve said repeatedly that I like stories where the bad guys get the jump on the good guys — because that’s what history actually looks like. And it’s more exciting. Telling the story about how the US Navy clawed its way back from the disaster at Pearl Harbor is a lot more interesting than “Oh, look! The new US interceptor arrived in Hawaii just in the nick of time to fight off the Japanese sneak attack!”
I could extend that to all of World War II, or the Civil War:
“Oh, look! The Union forces got the new super-duper Gatling gun just in time to crush the rebels at First Manassas! The war was over practically before it began!”
“Oh, look! The Poles got the new super-duper tank just in time to drive back the Nazi invasion in 1939!”
You see my point?